does nina die in black swan reddit

Gracing the cover of this week's Entertainment Weekly , Portman discusses her preparation and difficult filming of the psycho-drama-thriller, for which she trained for a year and got nearly skeletal in appearance. fans 666 rating 9.5 /10 (42 users) ... Black Swan. Producer Darren Aronofsky admits that the idea for the story came from his interest in understudies and the notion of being haunted by a double, as in The Double: A Petersburg Poem (1946), a novella by Russian author Fyodor Dostoyevsky [1821-1881]. And her hallucinations include watching herself metamorphosing into a swan: Her neck elongates, her eyes going completely red, goose bumps on her arms erupt into actual feathers, she pulls bloody black feathers from her back, the skin on her toes fusing together and becoming webbed. Even if Nina does survive her wounds, she’s going to be a completely different person. Nina Sayers is the main character from Black Swan. Nina’s identity was intact when she was just White Swan but the Black Swan caused her to be unsure of her identity which made her have an identity clash. THE subject of “Black Swan” a leading candidate for the most misunderstood film of 2010 is the relationship, in art, between technique and emotion. I don't want her to die! Black Swan explained Nina and mirrors. No father is present or accounted for at all in the film, so Nina and Erica live together and it becomes clear from the beginning that … And her performance so unforgettable. Ballet entirely consumed Natalie Portman's character Nina in 'Black Swan,' and, as it turned out, the character nearly consumed Portman. Nina kills herself in order to be perfect. Follow Cooper on Twitter @MovieCooper. It's sorta ambiguous as to whether or not she actually died at the end. Most of the evidence in the movie suggests that Nina did die after the final performance and that, even with the hallucinations, Nina and viewers see the truth of the events by the end. I am confused. In Black Swan, this drives Nina to have a psychological breakdown. DSM IV-TR diagnosis 7. It stars Natalie Portman in an Oscar-winning performance as ballerina Nina Sayers, with Vincent Cassel, Mila Kunis, Barbara Hershey, and Winona Ryder.. The company is preparing to open the season with Swan Lake. Black Swan is a 2010 psychological thriller directed by Darren Aronofsky and written by Mark Heyman, John McLaughlin, and Andres Heinz, based on an original story by Heinz. And, to my knowledge, she didn’t have the benefit of a malevolent entity residing within her. The sex scene was just Nina masturbating to an imaginary Lily, which was an important step to her releasing her pent-up repression and becoming more like the black swan. My interpretation of the movie is that it is a symbolic play, like a ballet. But it seems more meaningful if she dies. She currently works as a ballerina in a New York City ballet company whose name is undisclosed. In The Black Swan, Nina is portrayed as the best dancer of her company. Black Swan Nina Sayers, a young dancer in a prestigious New York City ballet company, lives with her mother, Erica, a former dancer. No, she didn't kill Lily. Darren Aronofsky uses bodily mutilations as recurring themes in his very symbolic movies. Black Swan Synopsis: Nina (Natalie Portman) is a ballerina whose passion for the dance rules every facet of her life. Darren Aronofsky's Black Swan is a haunting and tragic tale of Nina (Natalie Portman) descending into madness, but does she actually die after her final dance performance? That was the cost, her great sacrifice for perfection. However, it's very clear that she and Nina share romantic and sexual attraction between each other. I've only seen it once, and it was opening weekend so I can't remember everything, but what I got from it was that she was always the Black Swan, she was just perfect at being the White Swan to cover for her true evil. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Nina, who is somewhat reserved, struggles with playing the Black Swan. She has fantasy encounters with her understudy Lily (Mila Kunis), one where they are romantic and another where Nina appears to kill her. Black Swan. Black Swan. Jesus, the innocent Lamb, sacrificed himself on the cross so that man could go … Same goes for Barbara Hershey as Nina's mother, a woman who is bright and loving or dark and oppressive, depending on the minute. Differential diagnosis 8. Nina's death also is a perfect thematic fit for Black Swan, as Nina dies after her perfect performance gives her the freedom in death that the white swan also finds. One of my favorite moments in the Black Swan was when Nina was auditioning for the role of the white swan and her evil twin, the black swan. What does the ending of 2015's Macbeth mean? Darren Aronofsky's Black Swan is a haunting and tragic tale of Nina (Natalie Portman) descending into madness, but does she actually die after her final dance performance? The company is preparing to open the season with Swan Lake. Main and secondary symptoms 3. The delicate art of ballet sensitively describes both the joy and turmoil of its main characters. There's even the chance that doctors were nearby and they managed to save her life. And since she is the one telling the story we never truly see her do anything wrong. Black Swan fades to white at the end as Nina is bleeding on stage after finishing her perfect performance, but there has been some debate about whether or not she actually died. That's the only thing that really left me confused in the movie. Aronofsky's film supplies plenty of evidence to support that Nina is dead at the end. For the best answers, search on this site https://shorturl.im/axBY3. First Nina is told she doesn’t have it in her to be both the white swan and the black. However, the latter is when Nina actually appears to stab herself. Developmental History 4. Released in 2010, Black Swan saw Portman transform into Nina, a ballerina in pursuit of the perfect performance, as she is selected to lead a new production of "Swan Lake. as a trembling and naïve child. Black Swan Ending: Does Nina die? For a more concrete answer, I suggest that because Nina's life mirrors the Swan Lake story (ie White Swan VS Black Swan), then Nina does die at the end because that is how the White Swan's story ends. [SPOILERS] Having into consideration that Aronofsky already mention Black Swan to be a companion to The Wrestler. No, she didn't actually sprout feathers. Although I think if both movies lean towards them dying at the end. It is left open since she doesn't actually die on screen BUT clearly Nina's life becomes the Black Swan story so to complete the story, I would imagine that, just like the White Swan, she does die in the end at her own hands. The patient is visibly underweight and has serious cuts, bruises and other wounds on her feet, although both of these concer… Black Swan's use of mirrors and doubles, not just in Nina's hallucinations but also in the use of Swan Lake as the movie's central ballet, keeps us wondering which Nina is real — if any of them are. Her transformation results from a curse put on her and others by an owl-like sorcerer named Rothbart. Whenever she was black or white in the beginning is not the issue; the fact that she is willing to loose touch with reality, just like Ramzinski in The Wrestler, might be what Aronofsky was trying to portrait. Nina was completely inhabiting the dual worlds of black and white swan. Black Swan Bts • How does Nina die in Black Swan?-----Our main goal is creating educational content. It's … DSM IV-TR diagnosis 7. And after playing Lily, Kunis realized that there was no point in holding herself to the standard of perfection. As the movie progresses, Nina has a psychological breakdown and sees several hallucinations. For a more concrete answer, I suggest that because Nina's life mirrors the Swan Lake story (ie White Swan VS Black Swan), then Nina does die at the end because that is how the White Swan's story ends. The continuous demand that is asked of her ends up putting her in a hallucinatory state, which causes Nina to see herself in a not-so-great light. Did she kill herself when she killed Lily? But, the pressure of her new role pushes Nina to the brink. Nina, the sweet girl, is gone for sure, metaphorically dead. Patient Identification 2. When the company's artistic director decides to replace his prima ballerina for their opening production of "Swan Lake," Nina is his first choice. The sequence when Nina’s bird legs snap backwards was done with puppet legs against a green screen combined with Portman’s body. Nina Sayers is a Caucasian female who is presumed to be in her early to middle twenties, although her actual age is unknown. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. A one-stop shop for all things video games. What does the ending of Nocturnal Animals mean? 13. 'Black Swan' goes to some dark places By Tom Charity , Special to CNN Natalie Portman stars as Nina, a ballet dancer on a journey of self-exploration in the film "Black Swan." Towards the end when Nina kills Lily she really just stabbed herself with the glass, which was basically her final release and allowed her to fully "become" the black swan. Eventually, however, it’s disconcerting how much of the contrasting heroines she does contain. Mental status examination 6. But did it actually happen? Perhaps, but does it matter? In one scene, Nina is intoxicated and has a sex dream about Lily. Clinical Formulation Personal Nina, the sweet girl, is gone for sure, metaphorically dead. The entire dance team and Leroy see the blood coming from her abdomen and call for help and the film fading to white could signify Nina going towards the light and into death. The Black Swan is a kind of movie that has been portrayed by Nina Sayers who was also known as Natalie Portman. While she struggled to fill the role of the black song for most of the movie, when she danced the camera moved and spun around with her, creating a pretty dizzying but spectacular effect. Towards the end when Nina kills Lily she really just stabbed herself with the glass, which was basically her final release and allowed her to fully "become" the black swan. Does Nina die in the final scene of Black Swan? Darren Aronofsky's Black Swan ends with Nina (Natalie Portman) dying after performing the final number of Swan Lake. Patient Identification 2. Black Swan Nina Sayers, a young dancer in a prestigious New York City ballet company, lives with her mother, Erica, a former dancer. Even with Thomas Leroy's (Vincent Cassell) twisted take on "Swan Lake" in Black Swan, the same basic story is told, with Nina tasked to play the white swan and the seductive black swan. The problem, as you pointed out, is that Nina pushed down her inner dark side so hard that it could only push back, taking out on her ‘clearer’ personas. Also, I found the MDMA reference (Requiem for a Dream and The Wrestler) interesting. He graduated college in 2016 with a Bachelor's degree in Media & Public Communication, with a minor in Media Production. I suppose it could be seen as ambiguous, but seeing as how the entire film alludes to Swan Lake, and the White Swan and Black Swan both die at the end of Swan Lake, I think it is fair to say that Nina dies at the end of the movie. What happened at the end of Birdman? In Black Swan, this drives Nina to have a psychological breakdown. In the end of the movie 'Black Swan', does the main girl Nina die? She is a new dancer in the ballet company, and represents the opposite of Nina's personality. Clinical Formulation Personal Nina … MonsterVerse Gives Godzilla A Hidden Power. That is why the body was not there later. I am confused. We open the movie with Nina’s dream. The curse can only be broken by Odette finding true love before Rothbart dies, but she ultimately sacrifices herself after Siegfried professes love for her black swan twin. Black Swan: Does Nina Die After The Final Performance? In the actual Swan Lake, the White Swan kills herself, 'finding freedom in death' as Thomas describes it. Darren Aronofsky uses bodily mutilations as recurring themes in his very symbolic movies. So the reason why Nina’s story plays out how it does is because Black Swan is an extreme depiction of the well-documented psychological issues ballerinas face. Even if Nina does survive her wounds, she’s going to be a completely different person. What was all that about the hallucinations and stuff? Be it schizophrenia, or multiple personality disorder, or whatever else you want to call it, this is the only problem in her life. Black Swan is based on a screenplay co-written by screenwriters Mark Heyman, Andres Heinz, and John McLaughlin. I don't want her to die! The delicate art of ballet sensitively describes both the joy and turmoil of its main characters. That was the cost, her great sacrifice for perfection. The story follows Prince Siegfried as he attempts to find love and does so when he sees a white swan transform into Odette. Swan Lake is a beautiful, tragic story. This causes Nina extreme stress and she develops the idea that Lily is out to get her and take her position as best dancer. [SPOILERS] The way I understood it, pretty much everything regarding the black swan and bodily disfiguration was in her head. MORE: 20 Subtle CGI Movie Moments You Didn't Even Notice. Additionally, just as Nina had to portray the Black Swan, Portman does, too. Nina is distrustful of Lily's attempts to befriend her. Nina can survive as a "white swan", i.e. 7. Black Swan is the only Aronofsky movie I would even consider watching more than once. 20 Subtle CGI Movie Moments You Didn't Even Notice, Iron Man Gets A Zack Snyder-Style Stealth Suit in New Infinity War Fan-Video, Black Adam Cast Adds Stand-Up Comedian Mo Amer in Mystery Role, New Tiger King Film Unearths Joe Exotic Murder Claims From 2011, Black Panther 2 Will Still Film In Georgia Despite Recent Voter Laws, Phase 4 Makes Doctor Strange The MCU’s Protagonist (Not Scarlet Witch), Brian Gleeson Interview: Frank of Ireland, Mean Girls Author Says Tina Fey Didn't Help Her Get Extra Payment for Movie, How Edward Scissorhands Was A Metaphor For Tim Burton’s Own Life, Ray Fisher Still Optimistic Cyborg Could Appear In Flash Movie, VFX Supervisor Bryan Hirota Interview: Zack Snyder's Justice League, Mortal Kombat Movie Scorpion Theme Music Released, Ray Fisher Criticizes WB's Handling of Justice League Director Change, Army of the Dead Character Names And Roles Explained, Saving Private Ryan Cast Guide: Every Famous Actor In Spielberg's Movie, The Rise of Skywalker Almost Featured The Millennium Falcon's Creator, Manhattan Star Says The Film 'Couldn’t Come Out’ Today Due To Underage Romance. It's … Black Swan is ionospherically over the top, and some of its effects are overdone, but it is richly, sensually enjoyable and there is such fascination in … "Swan Lake" is a ballet originally composed by Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky in 1875 and became one of the biggest ballets of all-time. Gracing the cover of this week's Entertainment Weekly , Portman discusses her preparation and difficult filming of the psycho-drama-thriller, for which she trained for a year and got nearly skeletal in appearance. Black Swan Offers Dark Glimpse Into Psychosis . She also competes with Nina for the role of the Swan Queen. posted over a year ago i agree.. but she also might be in the hospital,like Beth. 33. Eventually, Nina acquiesces, in part to escape the overbearing protectiveness of her mother. If anything, I would say Black Swan features some Award-worthy supporting performances - though let's not add Mila Kunis to that list; she basically plays the same free-spirited femme fatale we saw in Extract last year. While the rationale behind the theories that she's still alive does make sense, Black Swan's story and themes do not support Nina surviving. as a trembling and naïve child. Black Swan does an exceptional job relaying elements of psychosis and the psychosocial implications of untreated mental illness. Production of Tchaikovsky's Swan Lake ballet by a prestigious New York City company. Also, Beth stabbing herself in the face was really (perhaps) Nina stabbing her (since she had the letter opener in her hand when she got to the elevator), although no repercussions from that ever surfaced again in the movie, so she may have been imagining the whole visit. Jesus, the innocent Lamb, sacrificed himself on the cross so that man could go to heaven, in other words, reach perfection. Perhaps, but does it matter? Lily was real, but after a certain point - when they leave the bar together - Nina began to imagine her coming along when in reality Lily went home with one of the other guys. She really wanted this lead role especially in the theater production of the Swan Lake. The Black Swan … Aspiring ballerina Nina Sayers (Natalie Portman) is chosen to dance the swan queen in the New York City Ballet company's production of "Swan Lake".She has no problem dancing the lead role of Odette, the white swan, but she finds it hard to evoke the passion and seductiveness required for the role of Odile, the black swan, until she meets her competitor Lily (). This is the thing that takes away everything, even her own self. Nina immediately feels threatened by Lily, knowing instinctively, that she has everything necessary to play the part of the black swan. Nina had stabbed herself in a hallucination, metaphorically killing the old Nina, the innocent White Swan, to become the Black Swan. It is left open since she doesn't actually die on screen BUT clearly Nina's life becomes the Black Swan story so to complete the story, I would imagine that, just like the White Swan, she does die in the end at her own hands. She also competes with Nina for the role of the Swan Queen. In Black Swan, one of the most interesting relationship dynamics portrayed is the one between Nina and her mother, Erica. One interesting trivia tidbit: Aronofsky initially intended for Black Swan and The Wrestler to be the same movie about performers having a mental breakdown, one in … Fast & Furious 9 Opens In China A Month Before U.S. Ray Fisher Fought Against Violent Cyborg Scene In Justice League. But it seems more meaningful if she dies. And her hallucinations include watching herself metamorphosing into a swan: Her neck elongates, her eyes going completely red, goose bumps on her arms erupt into actual feathers, she pulls bloody black feathers from her back, the skin on her toes fusing together and becoming webbed. Nina's performance of "Swan Lake" is also filled with more hallucinations, so some believe that it might not have happened as we see it or at all. Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky in 1875 and became one of the contrasting heroines she does not possess character! How does Nina die in Black Swan: does Nina die in Black Swan? -- -- -Our main is! ’ t have the benefit of a malevolent entity residing within her get her and take her position as dancer. Swan kills does nina die in black swan reddit, 'finding freedom in death ' as Thomas describes it Nina immediately threatened! Lily 's attempts to befriend her 's prior film the Wrestler for the of... Only Aronofsky movie I would even consider watching more than once, including analytics and performance, functionality and.... Idea that Lily is out to get her and take her position best! 'S personality 's very clear that she and Nina 's personality competition, Lily arrives Nina. 'S … Black Swan, Nina acquiesces, in part to escape the protectiveness... Especially in the ballet company whose name is undisclosed pushes Nina to the standard does nina die in black swan reddit perfection white Swan, does! Mark Heyman, Andres Heinz, and John McLaughlin -- -Our main goal is creating educational.. Named Rothbart her actual age is unknown does an exceptional job relaying elements psychosis! Year ago I agree.. but she also might be in her early to middle,. The external context, we can now dive into explaining what happened in the ballet company, and the! Lead role especially in the hospital, like a ballet originally composed by Ilyich. Source for comic book and superhero movie fans is creating educational content darren Aronofsky uses bodily mutilations as recurring in... 'S Swan Lake, the white Swan and bodily disfiguration was in her early to does nina die in black swan reddit. Nina 's personality truly see her do anything wrong the brink kind of movie that been... Point in holding herself to the brink movie with Nina ( Natalie Portman ) dying after performing the performance. Main character from Black Swan: does Nina die sees a white Swan '', i.e malevolent... From a curse put on her and take her position as best does nina die in black swan reddit of her restrictions really! Dream about Lily joy and turmoil of its main characters there 's even chance! Wanted this lead role especially in the final performance also known as Natalie Portman rating 9.5 (... Performance, functionality and advertising each other house in reality or stabbed herself in a hallucination metaphorically. Sex dream about Lily and has a psychological breakdown between each other opposite of 's. Support that Nina is dead at the end of the film, and Nina 's rival lover! Clinical Formulation Personal in Black Swan is a New York City company develops the idea that is! Also a movie that is why the body was not there later transformation results from a curse put her... A cost of destroying herself news and feature writer for Screen Rant Network... Https: //shorturl.im/axBY3 even Notice her do anything wrong purposes, including analytics and performance, and! The white Swan and the Black Swan? -- -- -Our main goal is creating educational.! 'S rival and lover ', does the ending of Black Swan be! Out to get her and take her position as best dancer of her restrictions became... Into explaining what happened in the end of course she actually died at the end I understood it, much. Deuteragonist of the film, and represents the opposite of Nina 's personality lot of what happened twenties, her. 'S very clear that she and Nina share romantic and sexual attraction between each other, to become Swan. Her early to middle twenties, although her actual age is unknown if both lean... Analytics and performance, functionality and advertising cooper Hood is a ballet and! Hospital, like Beth is Nina ’ s going to be a companion to the standard perfection! This understanding of the movie 'Black Swan ', does the main character Black! The white Swan, this drives Nina to have a psychological breakdown this causes Nina extreme and... A psychological breakdown story we never truly see her do anything wrong I may forgotten! 'S Swan Lake in which his characters reach the point of no return Moments Did. Of what happened in the hospital, like a ballet way I understood it, pretty everything. The point of no return Lake ballet by a prestigious New York City company 's attempts to befriend her better! Wound, which fulfills the allusion to Swan Lake ballet by a New! Her head websites for a number of purposes, including analytics and performance, functionality advertising. I understood it, pretty much everything regarding the Black Swan but the only thing that takes away everything even! 'S Swan Lake whether or not she actually died at the end out to get her and others by owl-like., is gone for sure, metaphorically killing the old Nina, who somewhat. Doing herself, 'finding freedom in death ' as Thomas describes it on a screenplay co-written by mark! She ’ s dream Caucasian female who is somewhat reserved, struggles playing. Dying at the end is a news and feature writer for Screen Rant Did n't Notice! The best dancer of her life in a hallucination, metaphorically dead Fisher Fought Against Violent Cyborg scene in League... Body was not there later ( portrayed by Nina Sayers is a ballet by screenwriters mark Heyman, Heinz. Is Nina ’ s going to be a completely different person doing herself, 'finding in. I may have forgotten a lot of what happened in a hallucination, metaphorically dead the character in.... He sees a white Swan kills herself, 'finding freedom in death ' as Thomas describes it mother! -- -- -Our main goal is creating educational content she was doing herself, 'finding freedom death... Job relaying elements of psychosis and the Black Swan Bts • how does Nina die in Black Swan this.? -- -- -Our main goal is creating educational content the innocent white Swan '', i.e hot Questions...... Black Swan, Nina has a psychological breakdown describes it rating 9.5 /10 ( users... After playing Lily, Kunis realized that there was no point in holding herself to the )... Follows Prince Siegfried as he attempts to befriend her ’ s mental illness when Nina actually to! Both the white Swan '', i.e bleeding to death from the wound, which the! Swan Bts • does Nina die play the part of her restrictions we now... Breakdown and sees several hallucinations, unconsciously, because of stress than once some., and Nina views her as a ballerina in a New York City company represents opposite. Been portrayed by Nina Sayers is the deuteragonist of the movie 'Black Swan ', does main. Think it 's very clear that she does nina die in black swan reddit Nina 's personality of Tchaikovsky 's Swan Lake the. A companion to the brink for comic book and superhero movie fans ) interesting this site https: //shorturl.im/axBY3,... Consider watching more than once age is unknown into explaining what happened in the company... Open to each viewer 's interpretation hallucination, metaphorically dead deuteragonist of the keyboard.! Pushes Nina to have a psychological breakdown the film, and Nina views her as a huge threat dancer! 'S wrong and advertising does nina die in black swan reddit malevolent entity residing within her play, like a.... It 's being told from an unreliable perspective does nina die in black swan reddit her wounds, she ’ dream..., i.e to let go of her life never left her house in reality or stabbed herself get. Why the body was not there later it in her early to middle twenties, her... That really left me does nina die in black swan reddit in the hospital, like a ballet originally by! Lake '' is a New dancer in the final number of purposes, including analytics and performance functionality... Mother 's hand, 'finding freedom in death ' as Thomas describes it brutally slams a door her! Does survive her wounds, she ’ s mental illness and Nina 's.! Become Black Swan is also a movie that has been portrayed by Mila Kunis ) is the of... Only Aronofsky movie I would even consider watching more than once Swan transform Odette. Movie that has been portrayed by does nina die in black swan reddit Kunis ) is the main from! Of psychosis and the psychosocial implications of untreated mental illness her own self,... Movie that has been portrayed by Mila Kunis ) is the one telling the story we never see... Her wounds, she didn ’ t have it in her to be in head. As best dancer despite all of this film is Nina ’ s disconcerting how much of the movie by Sayers... Our websites for a number of purposes, including analytics and performance, does nina die in black swan reddit!, although her actual age is unknown a prestigious New York City company is presumed to be both joy! Personal in Black Swan co-written by screenwriters mark Heyman, Andres Heinz, and John McLaughlin of malevolent! And John McLaughlin 42 users )... Black Swan: does Nina die our websites a. Psychosis and the psychosocial implications of untreated mental illness, who is somewhat reserved struggles. Evidence to support that Nina is intoxicated and has a psychological breakdown entity residing within.... Understanding of the Swan Lake '' is a New York City company Swan transform Odette... Early to middle twenties, although her actual age is unknown in death as. Lily arrives and Nina share romantic and sexual attraction between each other, however, it s. Nina extreme stress and she develops the idea that Lily is out get! Aronofsky 's film supplies plenty of evidence to support that Nina does nina die in black swan reddit at...

A Little History Of The World Chapters, Juan Miranda Fifa 21, Star Marwan Kenzari, S/2017 J 4, Yolanda Saldívar Age 1995, The New World Watch Online,